Best Things to do on Maui: The Maui Cookie Lady

Imagine home-baked giant gourmet artisan cookies made with Hawaiian flavors.  Delicious! The Maui Cookie Lady’s cookies are proudly featured by top hotels & resorts, and high-quality artisan markets.

Mitzi Toro began baking cookies in 2012 as a fundraiser to thank hard working nurses at the Maui Memorial Hospital for taking phenomenal care of her terminally-ill father. Mitzi was encouraged to transform her cookie fundraiser into a business by her regular customers who came to love her delicious product.

After building her own commercial kitchen and officially starting her made-on-Maui cookie production line, the company quickly garnered fans around the world from as far away as the UK, Japan and even Dubai!

The Maui Cookie Lady aims to get a new line of Cookie Butters to the happy bellies near and far by Spring of 2018. The company’s motto is: “To make the world a smaller place one cookie at a time.”

Popular flavors include Kona Coffee Espresso using Peaberry Beans, Pineapple Lychee Passion with Hibiscus Flowers, White Tea, Lemon Chocolate, Mango and Raw Maui Sugar, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Grown-Up Samoas (made with Maui Brewing Co.'s Coconut Porter craft beer), Butterscotch Kisses (made with Sammy Hagar’s Maui Distilled Macadamia Nut Rum, Butter Toffee, Caramel, Butterscotch Chips and Raw Maui Sugar)  and the Original Butter Rum Triple Chunker, their original cookie and best seller, with three types of chocolate (White, Dark and Milk), raw sugar with a hint of butter rum. Da Half Baked (Reese's, Snickers & Oreo Stuffed in Chocolate Chip Cookie & a Dab of Malt), a giant 8 oz Chocolate Chip Cookie stuffed with Reeses, Snickers & Oreo with Malt. Elvis - Banana and PB C'ptn Crunch, Elvis' favorite sandwich made into a cookie. Raw Hawaiian sugar and Molokai sea salt adds a wonderful local flavor the unique cookie combination with Butterscotch, Vanilla Caramel, Banana and Peanut Butter C'ptn Crunch Cereal.